The Legitimate Government in Hawaii Series:  A No Sovereignty Pretend Government vs.  The Legitimate Government in Hawaii, a Constitutional Monarchy Government

                                                                          Review by Amelia Gora (2021)

The following shows 

A No Sovereignty Pretend Government:

1)  The Provisional government Government of the Hawaiian Islands

case IN RE SHELDON/In the Matter of the Application of G.C. Kenyon On Behalf of J.G.M. Sheldon for a Writ of Habeas Corpus.

Sheldon was the editor of the HAWAIIAN HOLOMUA newspaper who printed the near accurate story of the overthrow of Queen Liliuokalani in 1893.

Discussion of how long the Provisional government could last was also discussed.

The move to turn the Provisional government into a Republic was also discussed.

Note:  over the years, there appears that the file at the Archive became smaller.  There are kanaka maoli who certified the files.

There are a few who have the records who could probably be called to testify to the above.

Reference:  Habeas Corpus Case of Sheldon vs. The  Provisional Government of the Hawaiian Islands, HAWAIIAN REPORTS, 1893, Volume 9, Supreme Court Law Library/Archives/Main Library, Honolulu, Oahu, Hawaii.

The Provisional government was Not a recognized nation, and had no sovereignty.

2)  The Republic of Hawaii replaced the Provisional government.

The move to change the Republic of Hawaii to Territory of the United States can be seen in this case found in Volumes 11 and 12.

In Volume 12, Territories were possessions of the American Empire and not yet part of the United States.

The United States operated with Nations that had treaties.

The Republic of the United States turned Republic of Hawaii became 

The Republic of Hawaii was Not a recognized nation, and had no sovereignty.

Reference:  W.C. Peacock & Co. v. Republic of Hawaii, HAWAIIAN REPORTS, Volume 11 and Volume 12, 1898, Supreme Court Law Library/Archives/Main Library, Honolulu, Oahu, Hawaii

3)  The Republic of Hawaii became the Territory of the United States then the Territory of Hawaii.

By President McKinley's Proclamation, he instructed the Republic of Hawaii's officers follow his instructions.

Reference:  In Re Ah Ho, et. al., HAWAIIAN REPORTS, Volume 11, 1899, Supreme Court Law Library/Archives/Main Library, Honolulu, Oahu, Hawaii.

4)  The Territory of Hawaii

"The Territories are but political subdivision of the outlying dominion of the United States  Their relation to the general government is much the same as that which counties bear to the respective States"....though strictly speaking there was no sovereignty in the Territory."

The Territory of the United States turned Territory of Hawaii was Not a recognized nation, and had no sovereignty.

Reference:  Mary A. Coffield v. The Territory of Hawaii, HAWAIIAN REPORTS, Volume 13, 1901, Supreme Court Law Library/Archives/Main Library, Honolulu, Oahu, Hawaii.

Note:  The Provisional Government, Republic of Hawaii, Territory of Hawaii remained an entity that was Not a Nation and had No Sovereignty.

From 1893 thru 1897 the Provisional government to Republic of Hawaii sat with no status, denied Annexation by U.S. President Grover Cleveland.

 

vs. The Legitimate Government in Hawaii:  The Hawaiian Kingdom/Kingdom of Hawaii

KUE Petition in 1897

Olelo Mua   |   "The 1897 Petitions Protesting Annexation" by Noenoe Silva

Begin browsing at first page

  • Hawaii, Women [Kona Hema, Kona 'Akau, Kohala, Waimea, Hamakua, Hilo, Puna, Ka'u]
  • Hawaii, Men [Kona, Hema, Kona, 'Akau, Kohala, Waimea, Hamakua, Hilo, Puna, Ka'u]
  • Maui, Women [Lahaina, Wailuku, Waihe'e, Waiehu, Waikapu, Honua'ula, Makawao, Hana, Honokohau]
  • Maui, Men [Lahaina, Wailuku, Waihe'e, Waiehu, Waikapu, Honua'ula, Makawao, Hana, Honokohau]
  • Molokai, Women [Kona, Halawa]
  • Molokai, Men [Pelekunu, Wailau, Kona, Halawa, Kalawao & Kalupapa]
  • Oahu, Women [Honolulu, Manoa, 'Ewa, Wai'anae, Waialua, Ko'olauloa, Ko'olaupoko]
  • Oahu, Men [Honolulu, Manoa, 'Ewa, Wai'anae, Waialua, Ko'olauloa, Ko'olaupoko]
  • Kauai, Women [Lihu'e, Koloa, Hanapepe, Waimea, Ko'olau, Hanalei, Kawaihau]
  • Kauai, Men [Lihu'e, Hanapepe, Waimea, Hanalei, Kawaihau]
  • ListsReport of L.A. ThurstonTables

and

Opposition to Statehood in 1959

Abel Cathcart supported by Mele Keawe Kauweloa opposed Statehood.

References:

You need to be a member of maoliworld to add comments!

Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • facebook:

      

     
    Active
    3m  · 
    Shared with Public
    Public
    Laws cited as to why the entity "Pretend" state had No sovereignty.....an illegal state with a shared 1/50 sovereignty under the United States with documented breach of the Neutrality law, etc. ..........keep for your records, share far and wide....
    The Legitimate Government in Hawaii Series:  A No Sovereignty Pretend Government vs.  The Legitimate Government in Hawaii, a Constitutional Monarchy Government
    MAOLIWORLD.COM
    The Legitimate Government in Hawaii Series:  A No Sovereignty Pretend Government vs.  The Legitimate Government in Hawaii, a Constitutional Monarchy Government
    The Legitimate Government in Hawaii Series: A No Sovereignty Pretend Government vs. The Legitimate Government in Hawaii, a Constitutional Monarchy Government…
     
     
  • Tweet:

    Conversation

    amelia gora
    @hwnwahine
    ·
    1m
    Checking out "The Legitimate Government in Hawaii Series:  A No Sovereignty Pr" on Maoliworld: https://maoliworld.com/forum/topics/the-legitimate-government-in-hawaii-series-a-no-sovereignty Why the State of Hawaii is Not a Legal State etc.
    The Legitimate Government in Hawaii Series:  A No Sovereignty Pretend Government vs.  The Legitim...
    The Legitimate Government in Hawaii Series:  A No Sovereignty Pretend Government vs.  The Legitimate Government in Hawaii, a Constitutional Monarchy Government…
    maoliworld.com
    1

    amelia gora
    @hwnwahine
    Replying to
    Kingdom of Hawaii (1795–1893) National Anthem "He Mele Lahui Hawaii"
    "He Mele Lāhui Hawaiʻi" ("The Song of the Hawaiian Nation") was composed by Liliuokalani in November 1866 at the request of Kamehameha V, who wanted a nation...
    youtube.com

This reply was deleted.